Return on Investment at the Reloading Bench — Part II
Where the Biggest Gains Actually Come From (and How to Make Them Worth It)
By Aaron Peterson — Founder, Hawkeye Ammosmithing
“Data-driven ballistics, tested & proven.”
Return on Investment at the Reloading Bench
Why Some Things “Should” Matter — and Why They Often Don’t Show Up on Target
By Aaron Peterson — Founder, Hawkeye Ammosmithing
“Data-driven ballistics, tested & proven.”
Precision shooting is full of practices that are technically correct, widely recommended, and theoretically sound—yet often produce results that feel inconclusive, inconsistent, or nonexistent when tested in the real world.Why Some Things “Should” Matter — and Why They Often Don’t Show Up on Target
By Aaron Peterson — Founder, Hawkeye Ammosmithing
“Data-driven ballistics, tested & proven.”
That disconnect frustrates shooters and fuels endless debates about what...
The natural follow-on question is:
If many small refinements disappear into system noise, where do the biggest, most reliable gains actually come from?
The answer isn’t a single trick or tool. It’s about quieting the system—from shooter to rifle to workflow—so meaningful improvements are able to express themselves consistently.
The System Must Be Quiet Before It Can Be Precise
Precision shooting is an additive system. Improvements stack only when larger sources of variability are already controlled.
If the shooter, rifle, or workflow introduces more variability than the change you’re testing, that change won’t reveal itself—no matter how sound it is in theory.
This is why some shooters see measurable gains from relatively simple processes executed well, while others chase complexity without seeing results.
The Human Variable: The Largest and Least Convenient Noise Source
The shooter is not a constant—and often not a quiet one.
Commonly overlooked contributors include:
- Adrenaline and stress, especially in match or hunting scenarios
- Cold temperatures, reducing tactile feedback and degrading trigger control
- Fatigue, both physical and mental
- Eye strain, particularly from prolonged monocular focus
- Heat and sweat, affecting grip, cheek weld, and visual clarity
- General discomfort, degrading follow-through and recoil management
Hunting Amplifies These Effects
These variables are often even more pronounced in hunting.
Early mornings, long hikes, extended glassing sessions, uneven terrain, cold or heat exposure, and the surge of adrenaline when an animal finally presents itself all stack against consistency. Sweat running into the eyes, shaking from exertion or excitement, and compromised shooting positions can easily dominate shot placement—regardless of how refined the ammunition is.
If the shooter cannot deliver repeatable inputs, the system cannot report repeatable outputs.
Rifle and Optic Setup: The Gatekeepers of Ammunition Feedback
Before chasing ammunition refinements, the rifle system must be mechanically honest.
High-ROI rifle considerations include:
- Proper bedding with no stress on the action
- Consistent, repeatable torque on action screws
- A truly free-floated barrel under all conditions
- Secure scope bases and rings
- An optic that holds zero and tracks reliably
- A trigger that breaks cleanly and consistently
- Proper length of pull and stock fit
- Consistent cheek weld and eye relief
- Correct parallax adjustment
Ammunition ROI: Where Effort Pays Off Most
Once the shooter and rifle are stable, ammunition refinements can finally begin to matter.
High-ROI Foundations
High-Quality Brass
Quality brass from manufacturers like Lapua, Peterson, Alpha, ADG, etc dramatically reduces internal-volume variation, metallurgy inconsistencies, and prep requirements. In many cases, good brass eliminates the need for extensive sorting or corrective steps entirely.
Consistency at this level removes multiple variables before they ever become problems.
Bullet Consistency: Better Than Ever—But Not Irrelevant
Bullet consistency matters, but it’s important to acknowledge how far modern manufacturing has come.
Most modern match and hunting bullets from reputable manufacturers are far more consistent than they were even a decade ago, and in many cases bullet-to-bullet variation is no longer the dominant limiting factor in a shooter’s system.
That said, bullet consistency still matters—especially when:
- Using older designs
- Using bullets with inherently asymmetric construction
- Using thick-jacketed or mechanically bonded designs
Bullets like Nosler Partitions, for example, can exhibit less concentric mass distribution due to their construction. That doesn’t make them “bad bullets,” but it does mean they can introduce flight instability that no amount of brass prep can correct.
In short: bullet inconsistency is less common today—but when it exists, it dominates results.
Powders, Temperature Sensitivity, and Node Stability
Powder choice is one of the highest ROI decisions a shooter can make.
Temperature-sensitive powders can shift pressure and velocity not only:
- Day to day
- Season to season
- Barrels heat
- Chambers warm
- A round sits in a hot chamber before firing
This can push a load off its node, increase vertical dispersion, and create accuracy changes that appear random or shooter-induced.
This is why proper load development matters so much—and why loads that sit in the middle of a stable node are far more forgiving than loads tuned on the edge. A wide node absorbs temperature, pressure, and handling variation without translating it directly into dispersion.
A load that is “perfect” only under ideal conditions is not a good load.
Sizing and Neck Tension: Quieting a Major Noise Source
How brass is sized plays a larger role in consistency than many shooters realize.
Traditional expander-ball sizing introduces several potential problems:
- As the expander exits the neck, it pulls rearward on the neck and shoulder
- At that moment, the case neck is largely unsupported by the case body
- This can stretch the case, partially undoing shoulder bump
- The amount of shoulder movement can vary case to case
- Aggressive expansion can induce neck runout, especially if alignment isn’t perfect
Even with adequate lubrication, the expander ball can:
- Reintroduce neck tension variation
- Increase headspace inconsistency
- Create runout that wasn’t present after sizing
A two-step sizing approach, using a body or bushing die followed by a mandrel, decouples these variables:
- Neck tension is set independently and consistently
- Shoulder position remains stable
- Runout is reduced
- Vertical dispersion often improves
For many shooters, improving sizing consistency yields more measurable benefit than numerous smaller prep steps combined.
Annealing: Powerful When Done Correctly, Harmful When Done Poorly
Annealing can be high ROI—or negative ROI.
When done correctly and consistently, annealing:
- Maintains uniform neck tension
- Reduces work-hardening variability
- Extends brass life
When done inconsistently, annealing:
- Introduces hardness variation
- Adds another uncontrolled variable
- Makes results worse, not better
If annealing cannot be done consistently and repeatably, it may be better not to anneal at all, instead managing consistency by keeping firing counts matched within batches.
Consistency beats intent.
Efficiency: Making Precision Sustainable
ROI improves dramatically when consistency is paired with efficiency.
High-value efficiency upgrades include:
- Integrated trimming systems that trim, chamfer, and deburr in one operation
- Consistent priming systems that control seating depth and feel
- Reliable powder dispensing systems that minimize charge variation
- Progressive presses, when used intelligently for prep or repeatable operations
- Arbor presses for bullet seating, where appropriate
Efficiency isn’t about speed—it’s about reducing handling, decisions, and opportunities for inconsistency.
The fewer times brass is touched, the fewer chances there are to introduce variation.
Doing Less, But Doing It Better
One of the hardest lessons in precision shooting is that more steps do not automatically produce better results.
Many shooters would see greater improvement by:
- Simplifying their workflow
- Eliminating low-ROI steps
- Focusing on fundamentals executed consistently
High-quality components often eliminate the need for extensive corrective processes. Consistency beats complexity—every time.
The Honest Truth About ROI
The biggest gains rarely come from chasing the smallest variables.
They come from:
- A shooter capable of repeatable inputs
- A rifle that behaves consistently
- Ammunition built on sound fundamentals
- A workflow designed to reduce noise, not add it
Once the system is quiet, smaller refinements can finally be heard.
Until then, they’re just whispers in a storm.
Final Takeaway
Precision improvement isn’t about doing everything—it’s about doing the right things, in the right order, for the right reasons.
Return on investment isn’t theoretical.
It shows up on target—or it doesn’t.
And when it doesn’t, the answer is rarely “try harder.”
It’s almost always simplify, stabilize, and listen.
Aaron Peterson
Founder – Hawkeye Ammosmithing
Data-Driven Ballistics, Tested & Proven
Founder – Hawkeye Ammosmithing
Data-Driven Ballistics, Tested & Proven
Instagram
YouTube
Facebook